Comparing and Contrasting BS 42001 v Bs 30440
Executive Summary
ISO 42001 is closely related to generic AI standards. It does not seek to surface fitness for purpose of AI systems in a manner that enables them to be used in healthcare industry.
ISO 42001 is closely related to generic AI standards. It does not seek to surface fitness for purpose of AI systems in a manner that enables them to be used in healthcare industry.
Sources of Evidence Required in BS 30440
BS 30440 -v- Other Healthcare AI Management Frameworks
Comparing Bs 42001 to sections in Bs30440
On consideration of sections in BS 30440. Here is our view on the overlap between it an BS 42001
Section 4 - Inception
Section 4 - Inception
- BS 30440 has more specific requirements around demonstrating that a healthcare need exists through objective and subjective assessments. ISO/IEC 42001 has more general requirements about understanding the context and needs of interested parties.
- BS 30440 focuses more on the healthcare aspects - involving stakeholders like health providers and patients, documenting data flows, using health-specific reporting guidelines, etc. 42001 is not industry-specific.
- BS 30440 emphasises diversity and representativeness of stakeholders much more than I42001.
- BS 30440 uniquely covers assessing carbon impact of the AI system. 42001 does not address environmental sustainability.
- BS 30440 requires healthcare-specific evidence like improvements in accuracy, cost, timeliness to show effectiveness. 42001 is generic in talking about effectiveness.
- BS 30440 stresses equity and bias in validation through sub-population assessments. 42001 covers this in risk management.
- BS 30440 covers healthcare cost/resources impact analysis and security vulnerabilities. 42001 does not go into this level of financial analysis or cybersecurity.
- BS 30440 emphasises user safety related risks much more strongly. 42001 covers safety more generically under risk management.
- BS 30440 requires routine monitoring of metrics like safety, bias, drift, transparency post-deployment. 42001 talks more generically about performance evaluation and auditing.
- BS 30440 tailored modification reporting, version control processes to ML model updates. 42001 stays high-level.