Potential BS 42001 - Bs 30440 Data Flow and Views on the Overlap
On consideration of sections in BS 30440. Here is our view on the overlap between it an BS 42001
Section 4 - Inception
Section 4 - Inception
- BS 30440 has more specific requirements around demonstrating that a healthcare need exists through objective and subjective assessments. ISO/IEC 42001 has more general requirements about understanding the context and needs of interested parties.
- BS 30440 focuses more on the healthcare aspects - involving stakeholders like health providers and patients, documenting data flows, using health-specific reporting guidelines, etc. 42001 is not industry-specific.
- BS 30440 emphasises diversity and representativeness of stakeholders much more than I42001.
- BS 30440 uniquely covers assessing carbon impact of the AI system. 42001 does not address environmental sustainability.
- BS 30440 requires healthcare-specific evidence like improvements in accuracy, cost, timeliness to show effectiveness. 42001 is generic in talking about effectiveness.
- BS 30440 stresses equity and bias in validation through sub-population assessments. 42001 covers this in risk management.
- BS 30440 covers healthcare cost/resources impact analysis and security vulnerabilities. 42001 does not go into this level of financial analysis or cybersecurity.
- BS 30440 emphasises user safety related risks much more strongly. 42001 covers safety more generically under risk management.
- BS 30440 requires routine monitoring of metrics like safety, bias, drift, transparency post-deployment. 42001 talks more generically about performance evaluation and auditing.
- BS 30440 tailored modification reporting, version control processes to ML model updates. 42001 stays high-level.